Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Was is Marigold, or the director? Ms. Baxter offers to go with him for moral support, and mentions that Barrow seemed out. Whatever the problem, this is a child who should be home with her family , and NOT going through the stresses of this production. Misery truly loves company and the depressed widow couldn't stand to see her sister happy. It's clearly just a case of the actresses needing to get used to the set. Can't put my finger on it. Tom tries to talk Lady Mary into giving Henry another chance because he sees how miserable she is. Others speculate that the child playing the part may have been sedated to keep her quiet. I refer to the actresses not their characters. There is definitely something off with Marigold. Finally watched the movies recently and I told my wife I Press J to jump to the feed. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Andy Parker later joined Downton Abbey as a footman at the end of season 5; Andy fell for Daisy and they became a couple by the end of Downton Abbey season 6. Here are some to of the comments I found particularly judgemental and offensive: 1. I don't know if they were just trying too hard to cast a baby who looked like Gregson and ended up with the most stoned-looking child in existence, or if it's intentional and Fellowes means to kick Edith in the teeth again by exposing that Marigold is mentally disabled or something and rousing another scandal. Photograph of infant Marigold; sometime in late 1922 or early 1923. Scarsdale Board Meeting, Viewers will see the Earl of Grantham commit the ultimate betrayal as he shares a steamy kiss with his maid, Jane, on Sunday night. I don't care: I'd say something, or give the kid back to happy family who took her in. Brancaster Castle, Northumberland, EnglandDownton Abbey, Downton, Yorkshire, England (formerly)Yew Tree Farm, Yorkshire, England (formerly)Geneva, Switzerland (formerly) Oh for Heaven's sake. There is definitely something odd about that child. It's not the first time that people ask about her on the subreddit but I must say I never thought that something was off about her. Edith showed her Marigold's birth certificate and revealed she was the child's real mother. SPOILER ALERT: Downstairs comes upstairs as Downton's Earl has secret bedroom tryst with his new maid. I have a downs syndrome child and he is grown now but I don't think she is down syndrome but she does seem to be a bit off. Titanic means distant cousin Matthew Crawley (Dan Stevens), a Manchester lawyer. As many viewers noticed when Marigold first appeared on the series, the actresses playing the character changed after only a couple of episodes. Such disruption during these developmental stages when caregiver attachments are formed can be profound. I challenge your knowledge of "Aspergers", which was declassified as a condition over 2 years ago when the new Austism Spectrum Disorder guidelines were introduced and your comment is only from 4 days ago. Tee Ball Helmet With Mask, Marigold and Sybbie were flower girls at Edith's wedding to Bertie Pelham. Marigold 2019 Downton Abbey: A New Era 7.4 Marigold 2022 BBC News 8pm Summary 6.1 TV Series Self - Downton Abbey 2015 1 ep Credits Actress3 Self1 IMDbPro Collapse below Actress Previous 3 Downton Abbey: A New Era Marigold 2022 Downton Abbey Marigold 2019 Downton Abbey Marigold Gregson (uncredited) TV Series 2014-2015 14 episodes Did you know Edit Michael Gregson (biological father) Edith Pelham (mother/legal guardian)Herbert Pelham (stepfather)Peter Pelham (half-brother) The dialogue was between the adults, and Marigold just sat there while they talked about the situation. Oh no. Several online comments by Downton followers suggest that the character was written to be autistic. Dickinson Dining Union Station, Get over it, not all children are extroverts, maybe the girl who plays Marigold cares only to go home to play while her parents want her to undertake the role of actress. We only see them for about ten seconds and in an environment that is completely unnatural to them. It's Edith's daughter. Stuck in Downtown Abbey Limbo for life because Edith's Obsession. Many of the footmen shipped off to the front; Sybil gave up her privileged lifestyle to become an auxiliary nurse; Edith learned to drive, helped out on a tenant farm, and brought reading material to wounded soldiers. 4. [A servant opens the windows in the library. Perhaps she is just bored with the whole process, by the time they get around to her part. - Downton Abbey Wiki | Why did Cora take Marigold back to Downton Abbey? or is seriously traumatized to fein the kind of passivity that is NOT normal for a child of any age.. either which way, there is something askew about dear sweet, young, appearing to be traumatized, marigold whoever is directing, producing, financing this $netflix money maker should have and hopefully WILL make the hard decision to replace their marigold character to those of us who quite frankly see what you see, this is inexcusable .. get on it do what you should have done. You people are looking way too deeply into this. Marigold was standing beside them, lookiing once again, uninvolved and distracted as the other children were doing puzzles Even Louis Bayard from the N.Y. Times wonders about her, asking, Isnt it time she starts to talk? It gives me no joy to agree with many there, but thr you have it, Geesh, such ignorance! The plot of the Downton Abbey movie is brilliant, not so much because it is surprising, but because it allows every member of the cast to do what we Being reintroduced to the residents of Downton Abbey is like running into old neighbors who moved out years agotheir faces look familiar, and you. Downstairs, Mrs Hughes questions if Marigold will ever be told of her true identity. On my millionth rewatch of Downton Abbey and I cannot stand Ethel. MC. Well, FINALLY. I wish there were stricter guidelines about this as this child is not getting what she needs being in this production, although one must assume she was well treated. Were you happy to see Lady Mary finally get whats been coming to her all along? She seemed a bit off to me as well, especially once they switched actors. Marigold along with her cousins, Sybbie and George, along with their parents, watch a small puppet show performed by Bertie and Tom. I think that the casting director chose the twins who play Marigold for their resemblance to the Edith character. Extended pharmacy delivery driver app; 5 ways to become more attractive. : , , . Welcome to the Downton Abbey subreddit, a place to discuss all things related to the show, the 2 feature films, the cast and the real-life history/context of the franchise. What is wrong with the child who plays Marigold in Downton Abbey? When Lady Edith integrates Marigold into the Grantham family, she identifies her as a foundling, taken in by the largess of Downton Abbey. I'd never guess Mary had a kid, but Edith wears that mess. Even once she's with the family, I don't think her character is supposed to seem as immediately comfortable since she's been moved a few times, so the little girls were probably just played out! Whatever suspicions and questions Mary had in her mind after finding out about Marigold are gone and she and Anna are back to braiding each others hair, making crank calls to boys and giggling. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! To those who have spent too long trying to read the bell board to learn the names of the rooms, this is for you (from the book, "Downton Abbey Rules for Household Staff"). Gray It's way too obvious and many people have noticed. Its a perfect storm and Lady Mary cant resist exposing the truth about Marigold. This is the official YouTube channel for D. Full episode guide for Downton Abbey Season 1 Episode 1 A telegram arrives and we learn the Titanic is sunk. The child stars returned for the Downton Abbey film in 2019. This is a list of characters from Downton Abbey, a British period drama television series created by Julian Fellowes and co-produced by Carnival Films and Masterpiece for ITV and PBS, respectively. Hair colour So secure does it appear that it seems as if the way it represents will last for another thousand years. Marigold (b. late December, 1922 or early January 1923) is the illegitimate daughter and only child of Edith Pelham and the late Michael Gregson. Liittynyt syyskuu 2010. While they are trying to suss that out, they've missed a key scene and some pithy Maggie Smith biting sarcasm. The work and court case that Robert F. Kennedy Jr. forwarded in legal discovery was that there has never been one safety study on any vaccine. 5. Her eyes are too hooded, in S.6 when she rolls out her tongue after being given back to Lord Grantham it is a typical developmentally challenged physical attribute and as one poster wrote, her facial expressions during such a scene ( and I've seen it in ALL her other scenes) her facial expressions are flat. It's way too obvious and many people have noticed. She tells her she cant begin her marriage with a big lie between them, referring to Marigold. No but their behavior is abnormal. Tom Morley. Though she considered passing Marigold off as her orphaned godchild, Cora tells Edith she wants her to bring Marigold home. After the royal visit, life barely returns to normal at Downton Abbey. Welcome to the Downton Abbey subreddit, a place to discuss all things related to the show, the 2 feature films, the cast and the real-life history/context . Two/three-year-old Marigold with her adoptive mother, Margie Drewe. July 28, 2021 - 17:56 BST Sharnaz Shahid. There is no possible way any of you are specialized to the point where you could diagnose a child with ASD (Autism Spectrum Disorder) based on 10 second video bites of a child acting. Tom takes Miss Bunting to the second floor. Thank you! Julian Wadham. Calico Pants I Think You Should Leave, Even Anna thinks Henry is right for Lady Mary, because he appreciates both sides of her. Furthermore, it is ridiculous to speculate the writers have any intention of exploring a autistic child storyline because if you were at all educated in this area you would know that this diagnosis did not exist in 1925, so there really is nothing to explore. Things are about to get steamy at the Grantham country house in Downton Abbey. It would be completely out of the show's character. There's something not right about the child that plays Marigold. Chaperones are hired to supervise the children on set and are independent of both the parents and the production. What happened to Edith's daughter in Downton Abbey? If anything, its a strike against autism, because they hate change. Same as older Sybbie, she had those droopy eyes like Sybil's. . With only one more episode of Downton Abbey left, episode seven proved to be a real emotional rollercoaster as I laughed, I cried and I even cheered for Lady Edith! Aspergers? Late December, 1922 or Early January 1923 (age 5-6) Posted on: 1/12/16 7:40 AM ET. Conspiracy theory: Lord Grantham and Matthew, Press J to jump to the feed. Things are about to get steamy at the Grantham country house in Downton Abbey. Meanwhile the pharmaceutical companies also benefit from total indemnification from injuring anyone with their products. Do they just pick children of the crew or something? Russet Brown And by the way, "Aspergers" is a mild form of autism and would likely not be characterized with the physical and behavioural attributes you listed above which are more likely due to a more severe developmental condition. Cora reveals Marigold will have moved to her stepfather's estate of Brancaster Castle in Northumberland by the end of Edith and Bertie's . As to your likening of Aspergers to a "dreaful [sic] impediment" is very short sighted as many people diagnosed with the condition as children, with the help of caring and understanding therapies, grow into productive, intelligent and socially adjusted adults. The Christmas clip is most telling. BAFTA Celebrates Downton Abbey - Page 11 at Issuu.com. It is unknown if her name was chosen by Edith, the Schroeders, or the Drewes. But Edith's aunt Rosamund Painswick decided it best to take her abroad to keep Edith's reputation safe. Click to Subscribe to Get Our Free HollywoodLife Daily Newsletter, Cardi B Reveals Kim Kardashian Gave Her Plastic Surgery Recommendations Before She Got Work Done, 'Downton Abbey': Lady Mary & Henry Talbot Kiss In The Rain, 'Downton Abbey' Shocker: Robert Vomits Blood & Collapses, Downton Abbey 2: Cast, Release Date and More, cant resist exposing the truth about Marigold, Chrissy Teigen & More Celebrity Moms Who Were Honest About Miscarriage, Funny Girl Tickets Are Sold OutHeres How to Still See Lea Micheles Broadway Show For a Discount, How to Prepare for the January and Q1 RPM Seasonality, General Hospital Spoilers January 16 27. Is Marigold on Downton Abbey autistic? Cora's mother travels to Downton Abbey for Matthew and Mary's wedding. Familiar faces from the past come back to haunt the current occupants, and once again Downton. The family is happy to go, but Mr. Carson does not approve at all. All goes well until Marigold goes missing. She is the third grandchild and second granddaughter of Robert and Cora Crawley, and therefore the third great-grandchild and second great-granddaughter of Violet Crawley and Martha Levinson. Possibly, Rosamund may have been counting the weeks or so that she knew that Edith was pregnant and then the many months in Geneva with Edith during her pregnancy. Downton Abbey Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. She tells Mrs Hughes, but Mrs Hughes insists they should not speculate, noting all they should care about is that the child is "safe" and "loved". Down syndrome children has definite physical characteristics which she doesn't have. Yes, she looks different, but the off-set photos show her looking more aware of her surroundings. Instead, Downton leaves its audience dreaming of an aristocratic life - where they might be as beautiful as Cora, Countess of Grantham (Elizabeth Those of us who agree with her will savour every minute of Downton Abbey, even the flawed ones. I hate it when adults want to pinhold a child into being what they think a child should be. This episode is all waterworks. Physicalinformation 2. Related: Cousin Isobel sees Lady Mary in the cemetery and tells her shes delighted she is ready to marry again. 1:06. But the kid will figure it out by the time she matures, like age five. And by the way, "Aspergers" is a mild form of autism and would likely not be characterized with the physical and behavioural attributes you listed above which are more likely due to a more severe developmental condition. As a mother of 2 children diagnosed with ASD I am very familiar with the condition and it didn't even cross my mind when watching the program. Bertie comes to the house and seems lovely, but the wheels are turning in Marys head. We only see them for about ten seconds and in an environment that is completely unnatural to them. It is not that she is tried, or doesn't understand understand what is going on around her it is the fact she simply doesn't care. Geesh, such ignorance! Lack of tracking with the eye, lack of eye contact, lack of emoting, lack of speech/delayed speech, lack of responding to inquiries and cues, etc. There's something not right about the child that plays Marigold. You are reading way to much into this,Kids are weird. Does anyone know if there were plans for the character to have developmental issues? I have no knowledge of what is wrong with her, but her eyes are hooded and she almost seems drugged, which I suppose she is not! Completing the child stars were the young twins who play Lady Edith's illegitimate daughter Marigold, who held hands with their on-screen mother Laura Carmichael. The only people who know the truth behind Marigold's parentage are. It is not that she is tried, or doesn't understand understand what isgoing on around herit is the factshe simply doesn't care. But outside of the ITV series, it seems that they haven't acted in anything else, according to their IMDb pages. why not bring up even Down Syndrome while we're at? But if and when Downton Abbey 3 happens, a time jump will occur and the children should be nearly entering their teenage years. Downton Abbey Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. Not even Downton Abbey could escape the impact of the Great War. And by the way, "Aspergers" is a mild form of autism and would likely not be characterized with the physical and behavioural attributes you listed above which are more likely due to a more severe developmental condition. Downton Abbey: A New Era's teaser trailer confirmed that Daisy and Andy get married in the sequel, but will they wed offscreen or during the film? It's hard to watch. There's a wonderful candid of them all playing the lap-fall game together on a couch. What is wrong with the child who plays Marigold in Downton Abbey? Is she Autistic? . He was the employer and lover of Lady Edith Crawley, and the late father of her only daughter, Marigold. Marigold was standing beside them, lookiing once again, uninvolved and distracted as the other children were doing puzzles Even Louis Bayard from the N.Y. Times wonders about her, asking, Isnt it time she starts to talk? Female Kennedys recent book outlines the huge increase in autism since vaccine onset just a few decades ago. Once the family hears the news of Barrows suicide attempt, Lady Mary pins it on her father for trying to fire him. There was something that didn't look right. It's been said that the children tire quickly, and get bored, and so their "parents" play with them to keep up their interest. Title(s) I worked for years as a chaperone in TV, film and theatre. I think kids in general have stricter rules around how long they can work so hiring quiet kids for scenes helps speed up filming. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. She was born in Geneva, Switzerland, and given up for adoption to Mr and Mrs Schroeder after her mother breastfed her. Down syndrome children has definite physical characteristics which she doesn't have. She was played by twins Eva and Karina Samms. She tells her to make peace with her sister and herself. As a mother of 2 children diagnosed with ASD I am very familiar with the condition and it didn't even cross my mind when watching the program. r/DowntonAbbey In my opinion Charles Blake was the only male on the show who had chemistry and a real connection with Mary after Matthew of course, I still can't get . Lucy Maud Montgomery penned Magic for Marigold in 1929. Born Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! I thought the same years ago and mentioned to a family member. Rosamund objects, but Cora puts her plan into motion. Titanic means . As a teacher who has worked with children with many types of disabilities, I, too, have noticed a disconnect with the actions of Marigold. Includes character biography, gallery, and a complete list of episode appearances. Marigold with her birth mother, maternal grandparents, and cousin, Marigold's mother (left) with her two maternal aunts, Marigold (age two-three) happily playing with her toys. "not right", really, who are you to say what is and what isn't "right"? I think there is something off with you for thinking that. There's something not right about the child that plays Marigold. If the writers don't plan to include a challenged child in the plot (and unveil it soon), I think it's very poor casting and it draws attention away from the story line because viewers - instead of paying attention to the plot - sit there thinking, "What the heck is wrong with Marigold?" Do you watch Downton Abbey more for the fashion than those dramatic plotlines? I thought she was just shy !! Neil McCarty. That only meant that she was not a natural actress. Before she was born, her mother had first considered having an abortion (because she feared becoming an outcast for having an illegitimate child, Michael having mysteriously vanished in Germany without a trace) but backed out at the last minute. There's something not right about the child that plays Marigold. A wedding and a suicide attempt shock the house. Is diversity non existent in your world? Cora's mother travels to Downton Abbey for Matthew and Mary's wedding. Oh, I dunno. Mr Drewe suspects that his wife took Marigold back to their home at Yew Tree Farm when he realizes she's missing also and has taken their truck. Familyinformation Marigold was standing beside them, lookiing once again, uninvolved and distracted as the other children were doing puzzles Even Louis Bayard from the N.Y. Times wonders about her, asking, Isnt it time she starts to talk? Behindthescenes So your judgements are based on viewing upwards of 4 to 6 different people, not just one. Meanwhile, any future daughters Edith may have would be "Lady [First name] Pelham." Portrayed by Artifact Title: In-Universe: Downton Abbey was actually a monastery when it was built in the Middle Ages; after the Dissolution of the Monasteries it was seized and In season 6, Mary, out of total spite, forces Edith to reveal to her fiance that Marigold is Edith's daughter. It's wild and overwhelming and this is simply a baby or one of twins, who is tired, over-loaded, confused, trying to pick her own parent out of the crowd of strangers (yes, she's seen them before, but they are not part of her small world), lights, poles, cords, machinery, people constantly infereing etc. Several online comments by Downton followers suggest that the character was written to be autistic. It's way too obvious and many people have noticed. Any are you actually suggested the show use the Dowager's Countess' sarcasm to mock a child who may have a developmental disability. Either way - what an odd choice for a child actor. I'm watching episode 8 of season 5, and Marigold is sitting on Edith's lab. Downton abbey - morning]. Downton Abbey: The Exhibition. That doesn't sound dreadful to me. Why did Eren see the future when he touched Historias hand? Tom serves as the best man for the wedding, for the second time. A blog about Decorating, fashion, gardens, the beach, gardening, cooking, photography, all influenced by my Italian and Argentine roots. Hes still very interested in Lady Edith, but she cant bring herself to tell him about Marigold. Downton Abbey (2010). You're not the only one that noticed. Edith is deeply moved, and later Tom reveals he knows the truth as well, saying where he grew up "there were quite a few Marigolds" - his cousin Nuala had had a daughter out of wedlock who was brought up as her sister, and though the family never talked about it, they all knew the truth. I agree. chill out, seriously. You really think those kids look like Gregson? Well, her behavior in season six, episode seven was so deplorable even I couldn't justify it. The same instance when the thre children were playing in thr library, foused and alert. Bertie storms off and says he cant marry someone he doesnt trust, or someone who doesnt trust him. This has to be a director's choice to make Marigold have a flat affect. She is very trustworthy, polite, and loyal to the Crawley family and her "downstairs" co-workers. Philip Wallace. ", Late December, 1922 or Early January 1923 (age 5-6). A major and ongoing plot in the later seasons of "Downton" involves Lady Edith's illegitimate daughter, Marigold. 2. That doesn't sound dreadful to me. Careful, people will think youre jealous dear and we dont want that, her mother warns her. It was so noticeable to me that i sat up and paid attention if she seemed happy. Lady Edith returns for Marys wedding day, saying that one day: Our shared memories will mean more than our mutual dislike. Shes being the better person and it feels like weve finally turned a page on the torture they, (well, mostly Mary), put each other through. Autistic children often look perfectly "right". Downton Abbey season 6. I am on my 2nd re-watch of the series and find myself again strongly noticing how spaced out and withdrawn the little girls playing Marigold seem, especially in comparison to George and Sybbie. MORE: Everything we know so far about the Downton Abbey film sequel In the sweet snap, brothers Oliver and Zac Barker - who play Master George Crawley - Fifi Hart who stars as Lady Sibby and. I have a downs syndrome child and he is grown now but I don't think she is down syndrome but she does seem to be a bit off. Hopefully this should melt the miserable ice queens heart, for good. If she was just "bored or tired" they should have picked a more animated child for the part. Carson and Mrs. Hughes take their shoes off and wade. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. DwntnAbby Fan wrote: I challenge your knowledge of "Aspergers", which was declassified as a condition over 2 years ago when the new Austism Spectrum Disorder guidelines were introduced and your comment is only from 4 days ago. It probably just took time for the actresses to get used to the set. She seems to look off, as if she notices no one or anything. Recently is possible to find a disease to describe everything making them a trend. I think there is something off with you for thinking that. It may be a little unclear as to where Eva and Karina Samms are now, but you there's still a chance that you'll see them in the next "Downton" film. She goes to Yew Tree Farm and explains to Mrs Drewe that she is Marigold's real mother. I feel like all passionate DA fans would react like this. Honestly I found something lacking with the performances of all the child actors on the program, they are small children after all. Tom takes Miss Bunting to the second floor. 4. Now, time for an update downstairs. She shows her a copy of Marigold's birth certificate (she had signed it with her real name instead of a false one as her aunt had wished, because she knew she might need proof of guardianship one day). I felt bad for her. As the sixth and final series of Downton Abbey hits the box this September, we invite you to take a tour of some of the TV show's most memorable film locations - and help plan your pilgrimage to some of them. Horrible posts about Edith and her. The three eldest children, Sybbie (Fifi Hart), George, and Marigold (Eva and Karina Samms), are still children who innocently play and are warmly coddled in Downton Abbey: A New Era. That doesn't sound dreadful to me. In series six she reacted to her surroundings more. What? However, Rosamund says - in Episode 5.05 - that she spent "10 months" of her life making sure the baby came safely. Perhaps she doesn't like Edith? If the writers don't plan to include a challenged child in the plot (and unveil it soon), I think it's very poor casting and it draws attention away from the story line because viewers - instead of paying attention to the plot - sit there thinking, "What the heck is wrong with Marigold?" on Christmas Day 2015 on a relatively high note (unlike the 2012 Christmas special): Edith married Bertie Pelham - despite him originally calling off the engagement due to finding out about her daughter Marigold. In series six she reacted to her surroundings more. Downton Abbey Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. Find all 17 songs in Downton Abbey Soundtrack, with scene descriptions. If Marigold is officially adopted by Bertie Pelham, as an adopted child she would not be entitled to the sobriquet "Lady" usually accorded to the daughters of a marquess, but would instead remain "Miss Marigold [Pelham]" as until 2004, children who had been adopted by peers had no right to any courtesy title. Marigold appeared to be fine in earlier episodes so my first thought was shes just another casualty of vaccine injury. Then Mary unwisely takes Marigold along with her son George and Cora to the Drewe's farm to view the pigs for the Moulton show where Mrs Drewe suddenly appears and has an emotional reunion with Marigold, whom she has clearly not got over even though its been months since the little girl left Yew Tree Farm. When Rosamund and Violet learn Edith brought Marigold back, they insist on having her taken out of England again, possibly to a boarding school in France. She is the third grandchild and second granddaughter of Robert and Cora Crawley, and therefore the third great-grandchild and second great-granddaughter of Violet Crawley and Martha Levinson. It gives me no joy to agree with many there, but thr you have it. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. The death of his heir aboard R.M.S. Pictures Of Sandwiches With Names, do fungi have cell walls made of cellulose. I think we should all feel more comfortable about the changes in the child if we were told that they were, in fact, two different actors, and not just twins. But when Edith receives confirmation that Michael has been long dead, she decides she cannot stay in Downton and be happy. It is not that she is tried, or doesn't understand understand what is going on around her it is the fact she simply doesn't care. But after returning, Edith was troubled at having to give up her child. Easier to film than a chipper toddler who is on the go and has a million questions! . Think Nurture not just Nature. 9 likes.
Ramah Reed Wright, Articles M